Hi! This may be odd questions, but I’m curious and I hope you could clear them for me. Do you know when were the Water Gardens and Summerhall built? If not, can you speculate? Also, how long would it take for palaces like that to be built? Thank you :)

This one I can do. Summerhall began construction in 188 AC, and was inhabited by 209 although probably before. 

The Water Gardens began construction in 187 AC, although how long it took to be finished I’m not sure although from AFFC it seems to have taken a few years but not much longer.

In terms of general construction times, several years to several decades, depending on the complexity of construction. In these cases, Summerhall is a small and not particularly well-fortified castle, which cuts down on time, and the Water Gardens are a pleasure palace, so again you don’t need to build defenses. 

What are your top 5 moments of political theatre in ASOIAF (books 1-5)?

Political theater, you say? Hmm…hard to pick five total. I’ll go with five per.

AGOT – the trial at Darry, Ned sending out Ser Beric, the throne room confrontation, the execution, and “King in the North!" 

ACOK – Stannis’ public letter, the Tourney at Bitterbridge, Stannis and Renly meeting, Tyrion in the throne room (Tyrion 

ASOS – Robb holding court in Riverrun, the Red Wedding, the Purple Wedding, Tyrion’s trial. 

AFFC – Tommen and Margaery’s wedding, Cersei’s meeting with the High Sparrow, the two queen’s trials. 

ADWD – Davos in Wyman Manderly’s court, Dany in the Pit. 

TWOW – "The Bloody Hand,” by Phario Forel. 

Oberyn wasn’t alive when Doran sent Quentyn to Essos? Quentyn’s Essosi journey must have been in the works a long time and must have taken him a long time to get there. Couldn’t Doran have sent Oberyn to Essos, and Quentyn or Arianne to King’s Landing?

I think Oberyn insisted on going to KL, and according to the timeline, Oberyn left for KL a month before Quentyn left Plankytown and when Quentyn left, Oberyn’s death was known in Sunspear for some time as it had happened well over two weeks prior. 

Is Doran Martell’s reputation as a master planner deserved? So far we’ve seen two concrete plans: 1.) sign a marriage contract between Viserys and Arriane, but there’s no way Dorne plus whatever army Viserys could gin up would be able to beat the Baratheon/Stark/Arryn/Tully/Lannister alliance that was solidly in place when the marriage contract was signed. 2.) Send Quentyn with 6 men to bring Dany home – a job which everyone (even Quentyn) agrees Quentyn is wildly unsuited for. Why the love?

1. I think the original intention was that Viserys’ army would include forces from Braavos and Tyrosh, possibly the Golden Company or a khalasar. And I’m absolutely sure that Doran meant to destroy at least the Lannister part of that alliance. 

2. If Oberyn had been alive, I think he would have sent Oberyn. 

thefingerfuckingfemalefury:

dragondicks:

tarajenkins:

fandomsandfeminism:

seanksii:

finally

-evil laughter-

A fine example of the mysteriously selective freedom to be found beyond the gate of game.

what’s great is that last year, when Sam Wilson became the current Captain America, the comics made fun of this exact mindset

image

100% chance the person who wrote this article only ventures out of their parents basement to heat something up in the microwave (Having been too stupid and/or lazy to ever learn how to work an oven much like they failed to learn any skills that would make them employable) before descending back into their foul smelling lair

And that their only contact with other human beings are the teenagers they swear at while playing Call of Duty

I love this! Breitbart got pre-mocked!

This may come up in your Blackfyre essays (which I’m stoked about) but do you think its weird that we know so little about the war itself at this point. The only named/discussed battle is Redgrass Field. I was expecting a detailed overview of the war in the Daeron II section of the World Book, similar to the Dance in the Aegon II section, but there was barely any new info. Doesn’t seem likely that he’d be saving it for a future D&E story. Any thoughts?

“The Blacks and the Reds, Part II” will examine the First Blackfyre Rebellion in detail from the outbreak to the aftermath of Redgrass Field.

I have a detailed theory about the arc of the war, along with a bunch of battles that are discussed here and there. Sworn Sword and Mystery Knight have quite a bit of info if you know where to look. 

I’m re-reading ADWD & hung up on Davos I. There’s world-building with a view of the Sisters & more color on guest right, but the purpose seems to be: 1) revealing that Wyman is to declare for Tommen and 2) Ned returned to WF via the Sisters at the start of Robert’s Rebellion & Godric says the fisherman’s daughter is Jon Snow’s mother. #1 could be handled in the next Davos chapter, meaning the only point is #2, which is rarely discussed. Is GRRM just trolling? Red herring or something more?

Not so much red herring as false trail – I think Eddard made it a point to spread the Wylla story around a bit to help hide Jon’s parentage. He may even have taken a boat from KL to White Harbor via the Sisters specifically to blur people’s memories with his first trip. 

I was reading TWOIAF and Aegon V’s story is an interesting parallel to Tywin. In that Aegon V had children who rebelled against his wishes but he couldn’t reign them in, whereas Tywin keeps his children in line by any means. Duncan Targaryen/Jenny of Oldstones echoes Tyrion/Tysha. Considering Tywin won fame for reversing Aegon V’s reforms, do you think he saw his story and his actions as a cautionary tale on how to discipline kids?

An interesting question. I don’t think Tywin thought much of Aegon V as king – for one thing, their political projects seem completely opposed and I think you’re right about the kids. Also, I think Tywin probably resented the way in which Aegon kept intervening in the West because of Tytos’ weakness, such that Aegon was a reminder of how far the Lannisters had fallen. 

But this leads me to wonder – who did and didn’t support Aegon V? There were clearly rebellions in the Westerlands and Stormlands, and I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the Brackens rebelled what with a Blackwood as the Queen. I could see the Reach as also a potential area for rebellion, given the marriage crisis and the Reach’s more heavy emphasis on chivalry and social caste.

I’m guessing Aegon V found a warmer reception in Dorne, both because he had both Martell and Dayne blood and because of the Dornish belief in collective social responsibility. I wonder if a young and idealistic Jon Arryn approved or disapproved?  

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Daenerys II, ACOK

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Daenerys II, ACOK

Qarth

All the colors that had been missing from Vaes Tolorro had found their way to Qarth; buildings crowded about her fantastical as a fever dream in shades of rose, violet, and umber. 

Synopsis: Daenerys and her dragons arrive in Qarth to rapturous applause. Dany takes up residence at the house of Xaro Xhoan Daxos, gets an invitation from Pyat Pree to visit the House of the Undying, and receives…

View On WordPress