How did you come to estimate 2 million highborn in Westeros? That is so so much higher than I was thinking!! Have a good day :)

jeff22003:

racefortheironthrone:

Well, the population of Westeros is around 40 million, and medieval European societies tended to have around 5% or so of the population as the nobility, with some as low as around 1% and some as high as 10%. 

That makes sense even in the modern US with the 1% vs 99% stuff that’s still 3 million out of over 300 million people. In Westeros when you say highborn you are not just talking about the Lannisters, Hightowers and the Arryns. You are talking about the Osgreys, the Smallwoods, and Podric Payne who: 

was born a member of a lesser branch of House Payne. His father was a squire to richer cousins and his mother was a chandler’s daughter. He was still highborn enough to save him from Tywin’s noose. 

Yes. And just as today, there’s enormous amounts of stratification between the top 9% and the top 1%, and the top .99% and the top .01%, and so on, you’d have the same thing with the nobility with around 100 people in the Great Houses at the start of the series (so the top 0.0000025), who are above a few hundred or a few thousand principal lesser Houses, then probably tens of thousands in all the minor houses, with the overwhelming majority of the nobility being landed knights, household knights, and hedge knights. 

cleolinda:

1) Y’all, I didn’t realize how many people here had not heard about the MRA “boycott” of Mad Max: Fury Road. It is KIND OF AMAZING. Turns out, the movie is actually about Charlize Theron badassing women to safety in an post-apocalyptic etc. etc., and they are PISSED.

2) Coincidentally, it’s a “masterpiece” at 99% on Rotten Tomatoes and everyone who’s managed to peel themselves out of the theater reports that their faces were rocked off. 

3) Everything about it on my Twitter timeline today has been gold. I am now collecting things on Storify (actual links to the reviews and articles are there).

4) I’M GOING TO SEE IT TOMORROW AND I WILL REPORT BACK

Can’t wait to see this film. Also, what I find bizarre about the MRAs fetishizing the original films is that they have some of the thickest gay subtext of any action film I’ve ever seen – even more so than Top Gun. 

I kind wish instead of Beron Stark fighting the ironborn, he died in the battle against Raymun Redbeard (an event that actually mentioned by Jon in ASOIAF proper) since Kings-Beyond-The-Wall are a rarer event. It’s related to the events of ASOIAF proper (I guess that ironborn invading the North is as well). Don’t know how Artos the Implacable fits into the She-Wolves ruling Winterfell, but more interested in that especially neat for a Southerner like Dunk’s take on a wildling uprising.

It would be kind of cool, but the timelines don’t quite work for what GRRM wants to do. Dunk and Egg’s visit is supposed to be around 212-213 AC, when Beron is dying and Artos and Willam are probably pre-teens and Egg is around the same age (interestingly, this’ll be the first time that Egg’s spent time with his peers in a long time). 

By 226 AC, when Raymun shows up for his appointment with destiny at Long Lake, Egg’s grown up, he’s gotten married, he’s starting to have kids, and he’s on the verge of becoming king. That’s a very different story. 

I like the sense of history in the books that comes from the long-lived noble houses. But is it unrealistic for medieval noble families to last that long? I’ve heard that something like a quarter of English noble lines went extinct every generation.

Highly unrealistic. The oldest dynasty in human history doesn’t come to a quarter of House Stark’s longevity, for example. 

But that’s all part of GRRM’s issues with numbers.