More likely female heirs keep the name and their kids take their names.
Category: Uncategorized
Kickstarter Update!

Hey folks! So, as you might have guessed, we didn’t get quite to the original goal of $15,000, but we got pretty damn close at $9,729. And given that we got that close, it would be a shame to have the project fail and no one get the rewards they wanted. So I’ve started up a second Kickstarter with a more modest goal of $9,500 that will run for two weeks to make sure that people have enough time…
is it likely that the “church of starry wisdom” as mentioned in the Worldbook, found in the port cities of Essos and Westeros, is just another name for Melisandre’s religion? something i noticed, though i could be just reading into random word choices, is r’hller appears to be the sun personified, dragons seem to be related to comets, and shadowbinders–or at least quaithe–have a lot of starlight imagery in the narrative, which is a lot of space/star related images for the red faith
No. The Church of Starry Wisdom is a Yi Ti-sh cult, entirely separate from the Red Temples of R’hllor.
It’s also a Cthulhu reference, whereas R’hllor is a Zoroastrian/Manichean reference.
Is the frequency with which Lannisport sacked by Ironborn at all believable or is it a simple case of Martin hand-waving the second richest city in Westeros into a incompetent Ironborn punching bag. If you combine the City Watch (reputedly an excellent force) with the obvious militia formed from within the guilds of such a prosperous city (as you pointed out happened in real life history), shouldn’t it be impossible for reavers to simply steamroll Lannisport’s defences time and again?
It happened once with the Red Kraken, when the Dance had left Lannisport “thinly defended,” and that expedition was repaid in full by Joanna Lannister and Ser Leo Costayne.
It was raided a second time during the Greyjoy Rebellion, but there’s no evidence that the Greyjoys went further than burning the fleet in the harbor.
But that’s it as far as mentions go in the WOIAF. So twice in thousands of years doesn’t sound too bad.
Say Naerys died before Daemon (Blackfyre) was born a bastard and Aegon IV managed to marry Daena who then births Daemon Targaryen. In your opinion, would Aegon have had enough political “juice” to be able to bypass Daeron as heir in favour of Daemon without the pawpaw hitting the fan so to speak or would it still lead to war?
There would still have been a war – look at the Dance of the Dragons, after all. Any time that you have two great houses with succession claims on the Iron Throne, you’re highly likely to get a civil war unless assassination clears the decks.
I think the main difference is that Daemon’s position would have been a lot, lot stronger. Rather than being a legitimized bastard who was only a landed knight, Daemon Targaryen would have been known by the various lords as a Prince with his own domains. Especially if Aegon IV had pulled a Viserys I and gotten the lords of the realm to swear allegiance to him, Daemon might well have gotten the support from more than a few Lords Paramount.
But as the older son, Daeron would still likely have had the support of traditionalists like the Arryns as well as his in-laws the Martells, and probably the Lannisters and Tullys as in OTL.
Ignoring the Author’s world-building or plot development, is their a credible reason why we have had no mention of any “Being a Monarch for Dummies” books in Westeros, especially considering the abundance of books in circulation and the real life emergence of similar books. Maester Puppet-Master conspiracy or simply a thing for the (eventual?) Westeros Renaissance? RSA-fan
I think there probably are what were called mirrors for princes. Certainly that seems to be the intent of Tyrion’s gift of Lives of Four Kings.
Concerning Lord Borros Baratheon’s illiteracy, is it likely that he suffered from dyslexia (any other disorder) that prohibited him from reading or was it simply not that important to his father to ensure his son&heir could read and write? Education wise, Westerosi nobility are at least at 1300 (guesstimate?). Would it be common for a RL, lets say HRE Duke, to be illiterate? * In Tyrion’s DwD arc on the boat, he remembers his own math education dealing with shape’s and their “hidden secret’s”.*
Depends which time period you’re talking about – the earlier in the Middle Ages, the less literacy, and the more nobility you can find who think about writing as something that priests, scribes, and other servants do.
It is odd for someone that far up in the hierarchy to be illiterate, as Lords Paramount would be in contact with the monarchy and many vassals, as opposed to a lesser lord who would only have to deal with his immediate neighbors who he dealt with face to face.
Why would Bloodraven not try to attack Bittersteel in Essos, especially when he came into power as Viserys II’s Hand?
Do you mean Aerys I?
I would think that Bloodraven held back from attacking Bittersteel because a huge portion of the population had just died in a plague, followed by a massive drought and famine.
Westeros was a mess, nowhere near capable of invading the Free Cities, which would have probably brought in Lys, Myr, Pentos, etc. against the Westerosi.
You have mentioned previously that part of GRRM’s numbers problem is that Westeros is too large for a medieval setting. How were feudal kingdoms limited in their growth, and how large could they get before they ran into issues?
The basic problem was one of administrative capacity – feudal polities were incredibly dependent on the person of the monarch, and the monarch could only be in one place at a time and could only travel so far. And without a strong central bureaucracy, the monarch lacked any means of exerting control over far-flung territories that were nominally within their orbit.
So to give an example, the Angevin Empire extended from the Scottish border to the Spanish border, but it was very difficult to actually muster the resources of the whole nation, and as a result of the distances and lack of personnel the monarch was usually neglecting one part or another, which lead to rebellions in under-served territories and invasions by neighbors looking to gobble up some under-defended territory.
During the 1st Blackfyre Rebellion, where Daeron’s and Daemon’s families would be? Maekar’s oldest children should already be born, but Summerhaul doesn’t seem defensible enough, would they be send to the Kings Landing or to Dorne? Is Daemon’s wife and kids in Tyrosh? and how do you spread 7 Kingsguards between the king and all the princes?
Well, Daemon’s family were probably somewhere in the Reach, but close enough to hand that Bittersteel could get them out to Tyrosh.
Daeron’s kin were probably kept safe at the Red Keep.
As to the Kingsguard, you don’t automatically get one by being a prince, they’re apportioned according to need.