Simon Rumble: Dothraki in the Reach?

You have mentioned before that you did not believe the Dothraki could ultimately conquer Westeros. Surely they could do some serious damage though.

If Khal Drogo had landed on the dornish marches he would be primed to invade the fertile Reach. His army of screamers would hit them like the Mongols hit the Europeans. The Crownlands or Riverlands would be easy targets to.

Your thoughts sir?

The Mongols understood that you flank infantry; the Dothraki don’t. The Mongols learned siege warfare from the Chinese; the Dothraki haven’t. 

If Khal Drogo had landed in the Dornish Marches, he’d have to bring his men across the mountains to get into the Reach, and the Dothraki haven’t historically fared well in mountainous terrain. Hence the survival of Kayakayanaya, Samyriana and Bayasabhad. 

Also, Khal Drogo likely has never had to fight a battle that involves a river crossing. So I’m not so sure the Riverlands or the Crownlands would be that easy a target.

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Jon VII, ACOK

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Jon VII, ACOK

image

“Eagles have sharper eyes than men. We are seen. So now we run.” Synopsis: Jon and Qhorin have a significant conversation, Jon talks to Bran in his dreams, and then an eagle forces the ranging into a headlong retreat. Squire Dalbridge stays behind. SPOILER WARNING: This chapter analysis, and all following, will contain spoilers for all Song of Ice and Fire novels and Game of Thrones episodes.…

View On WordPress

Tradeoffs

elanabrooklyn:

postcardsfromspace:

On one hand: Jessica Jones is going to inspire a horrific volume of of sympathetic/sexy/tragic/eroticized Purple Man fanfiction.

On the other hand: It will probably also inspire at least one fairly solid story about Jessica and Trish and TV-version Karen Page kicking ass in a bar fight.

I am definitely thinking about this too. Will be quoting you on our podcast tonight. graphic policy @graphicpolicy radio is starting a new podcast series called Jonesing for Jessica.

http://www.blogtalkradio.com/graphicpolicy/2015/11/23/jonesing-for-jessica-episode-1-aka-ladies-night

Taping at 7 o’clock Eastern tonight.

In a small example of humanity not being entirely morally bankrupt, out of 167 Jessica Jones fics on An Archive of Our Own, only 17 involve her and Kilgrave. 

elanabrooklyn:

(via Jonesing for Jessica Episode 1 AKA Ladies Night 11/22 by graphicpolicy | Television Podcasts)

We started a new podcast @graphicpolicy radio. We’re talking about every single episode of Jessica Jones. One podcast per episode of the show. Each time with new guests – interesting people like TV and comics critics, journalists, academics, comedians. Actually, looking for a PTSD expert to join us too. 

If you want the perspective of smart geeks discussing the show through a socially aware, feminist lens then download us.

We’re available on Stitcher as well as on our site above. And by morning you’ll be able to download us on iTunes and Soundcloud.  

Have any particular topics you want us to cover> 

Questions?

FYI there is no Higgins or Birch street in NYC. But Soho House is a thing and you don’t want to bother with the scene there ;p

Tradeoffs

elanabrooklyn:

postcardsfromspace:

On one hand: Jessica Jones is going to inspire a horrific volume of of sympathetic/sexy/tragic/eroticized Purple Man fanfiction.

On the other hand: It will probably also inspire at least one fairly solid story about Jessica and Trish and TV-version Karen Page kicking ass in a bar fight.

I am definitely thinking about this too. Will be quoting you on our podcast tonight. graphic policy @graphicpolicy radio is starting a new podcast series called Jonesing for Jessica.

http://www.blogtalkradio.com/graphicpolicy/2015/11/23/jonesing-for-jessica-episode-1-aka-ladies-night

Taping at 7 o’clock Eastern tonight.

I was wondering what you think could’ve happened if Balon decided to join Robb or Theon convinces the Ironmen to attack the West with Robb? Would such a combination of amphibious invasion and eastern encroachment by the Northmen have left the West shattered and controlled long term? Could they’ve taken the Rock? What do you think?

I doubt the Rock would fall any time soon, but Lannisport certainly would. And while I don’t think the West as a whole could be held long-term, the Ironborn probably could hold onto Fair Isle and the Kayce peninsula for some time. 

Now, timing gets important here. If Lannisport falls long enough before Blackwater that the Tyrells hear about it, there’s not going to be a deal with the Tyrells and Tywin will be even more desperate to get across the Red Fork, which might delay him enough so that Blackwater resolves before he can get there. 

If it takes longer, then you might see the war pause for a second as both sides recalculate: without the need to retake the North, Robb now has a total fighting strength of 45,000 on the ground and potentially another 17,000 in the North he can bring down. That’s close enough to the Lannister/Tyrells’ 65-70,000 that pulling out of the Riverlands isn’t necessary. If Robb can defeat them in detail or force them into enough defensive battles that he can wear down their numerical advantage, he could win the war. 

In addition, with a powerful navy on the west coast, Robb could potentially threaten the Reach as a way to force his enemy to divide their forces and reverse the Lannisters’ recent advantage in numbers

How would you describe Brynden and Edmure’s relationship on the former’s end? I’ve heard people argue that Brynden undermines Edmure when he can and I’ve heard arguments that he’s merely handling areas that Edmure can’t and just being blunt about it. Do you think Brynden respects his nephew? Does he see him as a kid who’s in over his head? Or somewhere in the middle?

Well, Brynden backs up Edmure when he screws up the archery, unlike in the show. In the books, he only really gets pissed at Edmure the one time, when Edmure exceeds orders and screws up his and Robb’s plan. 

RFTIT Weekly Tumblr Roundup!

RFTIT Weekly Tumblr Roundup!

Hey folks, it’s that time of the week again! I’m still working simultaneously on Tyrion XI, Jon VII, and Sansa IV, which is a bit daunting but the writing is coming along well and I expect Jon VII to be up on Monday. There’s only one item of news – for those of you who are fans of the new Jessica Jones show on Netflix, I’ll be doing guest appearances on an episode-by-episode podcast with the fine…

View On WordPress

If Robb had successfully seceded, and had time to consolidate his Kingdom, as a Stark he would have to have his seat at Winterfell, but how would he exercise control over his vassals in the vulnerable “Southern Marches”, separated as they are by quite a bit of distance and the geographical barrier of the Neck? Is there a historical parallel? (obviously all of this requires some serious counterfactuals, like no White Walkers coming and a contested or weakened Iron Throne not coming after him)

Well, there are plenty of historical parallels when you look at the number of monarchs with geographically disparate kingdoms – the Kings of England owning provinces of France, the French owning Milan, the Hapsburgs trying to govern Spain, Burgundy, and Austria at the same time, etc. 

The success of any such venture ultimately comes down to a combination of good communication, delegation to local royal officials, the development of consensus-establishing bodies, and personal progresses by the king. 

Communication is, while not easy, somewhat easier than before when everything flows from King’s Landing. In addition to ravens, sailing from Seagard to Torrhen’s Square or from Saltpans or Maidenpool to White Harbor is a pretty short haul. Yes, Harroway’s Town to Moat Cailin is 700 miles, so you’re dealing with a two-week trip at the best to get from the heart of one kingdom to the border of another. But two weeks still allows for effective governance – the trip from London to Newcastle for example would have taken about 16 days at a moderate pace in the middle ages. 

You can already see signs of Robb developing the next two policies. Appointing Bryden Tully as the Warden of the Southern Marches means that he has a royal military governor in the Riverlands, but he makes sure that it’s a Riverlander and a kinsman so that there’s trust in both kingdoms. Likewise, having Edmure Tully swear his sword to Robb Stark means that the Lord Paramount of the Riverlands is formally a vassal to the King in the North – as with the Lords Paramount under the early Targaryen monarchs, the Lord Paramount is still going to be the supreme civilian leader and the 2nd most important military leader in the Riverlands as before, but Winterfell now has influence through future ceremonies of homage. 

Moreover, Robb’s policy of assembling the Lords of the North and the Riverlands together in council is a good one because (in addition to getting buy-in from his lords for royal policy) it gets the lords thinking of themselves as part of a single polity, and Kings of the North would be wise to hold mini-Great Councils on a regular basis. Separate assemblies are a bit trickier – the Great Council of the Riverlands could be a future basis for separatism – but that can be managed through regular appearances by the king to cement the feudal ties between him and his southern lords. 

Speaking of which, one of the ways in which monarchs project influence even within a kingdom is by making progresses and thus personally meeting and showing themselves to their subjects. If the Kings of the North want to hang onto the Riverlands, they and their kinsmen are going to need to make regular progresses in both kingdoms. It’s a lot of travel, but it does work. Progresses not only demonstrate respect for one’s subjects and inspire popular admiration through pomp and ceremony, but by offering an opportunity for local lords to lobby the monarch or settle grievances or judicial conflicts through adjudication of the monarch, it keeps local lords looking to the monarch for solutions.