In relation to your recent mercenary question where you posited that Tywin might use mercenaries as arrow fodder to avoid having to pay them as much, wouldn’t there be contracted remuneration for casualties that would ultimately cost more? I’m thinking along the lines of the mercenary company from Red Country (I believe you’re an Abercrombie fan?)

Well, that’s what mercenaries would like. But there’s a reason why Bronn and other mercenaries point out there’s no such thing as an old, bold sellsword.

I’ve read Abercrombie, but I dunno about fan necessary. 

What if Tywin had hired the Golden Company instead? He could afford them, they would be better in the field than the Brave Companions and at 10 000 professional fighters he may not have even needed to field Jaime. Harrenhall may have gone differently, why didn’t he? Or even literally any other company than the ones with the worst reputation? -A

Well, at the time the Golden Company was under contract with Myr and the only thing that can get them to break contract is the grand scheme to get their lands back. Also, given that Tywin fought against them in the War of Ninepenny Kings, he’s probably not on their most valued customer plan. 

In fact, Tywin’s failure to recruit significant numbers of mercenaries (the Bloody Mummers are both small and have a bad reputation even among mercenaries) in the War of Five Kings is a bit odd. It’s mostly a logistical mistake by GRRM – he admits that he forgot about the mercenary company who turned cloak after the Camps, for example. But my headcanon/No Prize explanation is that Tywin has a reputation for keeping mercenary costs down by using them as arrow fodder, so more discerning mercenaries avoid working for him. 

suppose that instead of sending 10,000 men to a frozen bog to starve for a year and die of blight, Balon sends a letter to Tywin offering to land the Iron Fleet in the Riverlands and join him against Robb Stark, if Tywin agrees to let him keep whatever parts of the Riverlands he can conquer for himself when the war is over. Does Tywin agree?

On those terms, absolutely. If Balon wanted a crown, he’d probably say yes and then go to crush him later. 

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Theon VI, ACOK

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Theon VI, ACOK

image
“If I die, I die friendless and abandoned. What choice did that leave him, but to live?”
Synopsis: Theon “wins” the Siege of Winterfell. And loses at life.
SPOILER WARNING: This chapter analysis, and all following, will contain spoilers for all Song of Ice and Fire novels and Game of Thrones episodes. Caveat lector.
(more…)

View On WordPress

Simon Rumble Asks: /lit/

Can you recommend some books/plays? Beginner, medium and hard difficulty? Thanks!

I don’t really think of literature in those terms. As someone who’s invested quite a bit of time in academic analysis of a genre fiction series, I’m not really much for the highbrow/lowbrow dichotomy and I think you can find intellectual engagement in a wide range of literature. 

So I’ll list what I’ve read recently for fun: Hilary Mantel’s series on Thomas Cromwell is excellent, I have re-read Steven Brust and Emma Bull’s Freedom & Necessity so many times the paperback fell apart, Ken Liu’s the Grace of King’s is a refreshingly non-Medieval European fantasy epic, I went on a huge Scalzi binge last year, re-read Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell again when the tv series came out, Ben Aaronovitch’s Rivers of London series is a rare urban fantasy that actually feels urban and fantasy, I love Robert E. Howard even though he’s massively problematic, Lauren Beukes I feel the same way as I do about Aaronovitch, etc. 

Simon Rumble Asks:

Obviously your main area of focus is British Medieval History. Do you have secondary field of interest ?

If we’re talking about my professional fields of study as a historian, my primary field is the history of public policy, followed by U.S history, followed by intellectual history, followed by labor history, followed by modern European history. 

But I’ve also studied medieval and modern Japanese history, Greek and Roman history, the Later Roman Empire, Medieval Europe, and economic history. 

People’s History of the Marvel Universe, Week 6: This Man, Magneto!

graphicpolicy:

People’s History of the Marvel Universe, Week 6: This Man, Magneto! #comics #xmen #marel

People's History week 6

Face front, true believers! When it comes to the intersection of politics and Marvel comics, the X-Men’s “mutant metaphor” is justifiably at the forefront. Up until now, I’ve danced around the topic a little because I lost a detailed set of notes that I had made on the original Stan Lee and Jack Kirby X-Men and Chris Claremont’s entire run and am still in the process of reconstituting my…

View On WordPress