So, if you’ve spoken about Jean and Scott, can you talk a little bit about Jean and her relationship with her kids? I think there’s a lot to unpack about Jean and Rachel and Jean and Cable. (Also, that wedding in July should be Kitty and Rachel, and everyone knows it.)

Good question (and you’re damn right about Kitty and Rachel)!

image

Jean Grey’s relationship with “her” kids is incredibly weird, even by comic book standards. 

Because she comes from the future of Earth-811, Rachel’s relationship with her parents has been affected quite profoundly by the fact that she comes from an alternate future and thus hasn’t yet and might not be born in Earth-611. This was more of an issue with Scott to begin with, since Jean was dead and Scott had married Madelyn and had Nathan (who didn’t exist in Earth-811), giving Rachel something of an identity crisis, and making her relationship with Scott rather awkward. 

image

When Jean finally met Rachel, Jean was dealing with having memories of her Phoenix self and Madelyn in her head, and thus was not quite ready to be a mother to a young woman she hadn’t given birth to (yet), especially given Rachel’s connection to the Phoenix Force through her mother, which brought up issues that the reborn Jean wasn’t ready to deal with either. So it took a while for them to gel.

Nathan Christopher Askani Dayspring Summers Cable is even weirder. He was born to Scott and Maddy originally, but then Jean subsumed Maddy’s memories, so Jean is in this weird

Schrödingerian situation where she both did and didn’t give birth to him at the same time that she remembers Scott abandoning the kid and other-her to be with her. But in the course of the original run on X-Factor, Jean dealt with her issues for Cable’s sake…only to have to give up the child in order to save him from the technovirus. And then the baby came back to her as a man who was older than she was, which is pretty damn awkward even if he hadn’t been a hard-bitten soldier from the future. 

So overall, the thing about Jean Grey is that she’s never been allowed to get pregnant, have a kid, and then raise that kid. Which I think is a damn shame. There are a ton of examples of how to make interesting stories about superhero moms and kids: Hopeless’ run on Spider-Woman and Slott’s “Renew Your Vows” (to say nothing of the FF, Power Pack, Luke Cage and Jessica Jones, etc. etc.) 

Thoughts on Cable

I’ve never been a huge fan of Cable for the same reasons that a lot of people aren’t – Rob Liefield over-design, ridiculously complicated retconned backstory, liberally “borrowing” from the Terminator 1 and 2′s aesthetic and tropes – but I was reading a bunch of articles on Cable that various sites are putitng out b/c of Deadpool 2 and I’d listened to the X-Plain episode on Cable’s intro, and I realized that there was something else that kind of bugs me about Cable.

image

He’s too many things: he’s both a powerful psychic (hence the glowy eye and whatnot) and he’s a military badass (hence the hardware that outdoes the Punisher for sheer tonnage). And often the comics haven’t really figured how to do both at once – hence the techno-organic virus, which is most often used as an explanation for why Cable doesn’t use his psychic powers, so that the creative team can focus on Cable doing one thing at a time. Which is both a bit of a waste and contributes to the argument that Cable is a juvenile Cartmanesque overstuffed grab-bag rather than a unified concept. 

But you know what would be interesting to see: rather than Cable just being a military badass in a universe that’s hardly lacking for them, what if Cable was a psychic who’d been trained to harness his powers for military purposes and nothing else?

image

After all, 616 psychic mutants are normally trained in more defensive and quasi-spiritual methods that make them the wizards and clerics of their D&D parties: whether it’s Jean Grey or pre-transformation Psylocke or Emma Frost or Charles Xavier, psychics generaly specialize in communications and coordination, protecting their allies via some form of shield, going to the Astral Plane so that they can fight the other psychics while the normies engage in fisticuffs, and they often get hit with various feedback effects or whammies just long enough to keep them away from the combat, once again separating them from the brawlers and bruisers. 

But in a future apocalyptic war against Apocalypse, I would imagine that the grizzled leaders of the Resistance would insist on a more applied approach to psychic powers, and thus you’d get a Cable who did things very differently: it’s a complete waste of his abilities for Cable to actually fire a gun by hand no matter how long and hard and thick it is (wouldnt be a post about Cable without some Freudian subtext) when he could use his telekenesis to remotely control entire platoons’ worth of firepower. Likewise, Cable’s ability to telepathically surveil and then disrupt enemy command hierarchies is far more useful militarily than punching people with his metal arms. 

So I guess what I’m interested in is a Cable who’s less 80s Arnie and more late-career Liam Neeson, Tom Hardy Mad Max, or Keanu as John Wick.