Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Daenerys IV, ACOK

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis: Daenerys IV, ACOK

image
“I don’t…I don’t understand….Help me. Show me.”
Synopsis: Dany goes to the House of the Undying to open the doors of perception, maybe play some prog rock.
SPOILER WARNING: This chapter analysis, and all following, will contain spoilers for all Song of Ice and Fire novels and Game of Thrones episodes. Caveat lector.
(more…)

View On WordPress

Do think Dorne could have be incorporated into the realm without the Conquest successfully? Daeron was unmarried and had three sisters, a double marriage united the Seven Kingdoms in one timeline why not another?

Oh, you mean Daeron I. Interesting. Part of the issue there is that Aegon’s First Dornish War had some really profound path dependency issues – the Dornish aren’t going to forget their kingdom ravaged by dragonfire, the Reachermen aren’t going to forget their kinsmen slaughtered in the sands or the raid on Oldtown, the Stormlanders aren’t going to forget their kinsmen mutilated after a prisoner exchange or the burning of the rainwood. 

Also, Daeron I desperately needed a big military project to unite the realm and restore the authority of the monarchy after the Dance and the False Spring. While he’d probably have an easier time selling such a pact than Baelor and Daeron II did, thanks to not being murdered under a peace banner, bringing Dorne into the realm peaceably doesn’t quite solve the problem. 

It’s actually quite reminiscent of Edward III’s position when he took the throne of England – recent civil wars, a king deposed and then murdered (although for Aegon II they didn’t bother with the deposing), defeats abroad, a long period of regency, etc. Hence the idea of claiming the Throne of France as a way to get the barons on-side with the lure of French territories. 

So maybe Daeron I could have looked east? Stepstones are a bit meh, but maybe a holy war to reclaim Andalos for the Faith of the Seven? That might have done the trick. 

Anon: House Bracken’s history

The Brackens have a history of being opportunists. They even kind of remind me of the Campbells.

When the Ironborn attack, Lord Bracken betrays his fellow riverlords to join them in hopes of a reward. He was an idiot to think it would be a crown. They also fought for the Blackfyres thanks in no small part to Bittersteel who was using Daemon to secure a place at the royal court. Now we see Jonos Bracken fighting his former ally on behalf of the Lannisters who attacked his fief without provocation, and burned his castle and raped one of his daughters. Something tells me he’ll join Aegon. 

On top of that, Bracken was responsible for “they lay with lions,” and isn’t loyal to his wives or his fellow riverlords.   

What do you think?

Honestly, I kind of feel bad for the Brackens, because GRRM has clearly picked them out to be an family of heels (in the wrestling sense), similar to the Peakes, Florents, etc. Compared to the Blackwoods, who are clearly his special favorites – they follow the Old Gods, they’ve got a special weirwood tree, they’ve got magic in their background, etc. The Brackens almost always end up on the losing side of any conflict – whether it’s the Dance of Dragons, Aegon IV’s mistresses, the Blackfyre Rebellions, etc. 

And honestly? I think the Brackens are probably in the right, to the extent that anyone can be in the right of a blood feud. Let’s take the origin of their dispute:

“The Blackwoods say they were kings and the Brackens little more than petty lords set on betraying and deposing them, while the Brackens say much the same about the Blackwoods.”

Given that the Blackwoods were originally a Northern House who had to immigrate to the South (”the Blackwoods of Raventree, whose own family traditions insist they once ruled most of the wolfswood before being driven from their lands by the Kings of Winter”), it’s a lot more likely that the Brackens were the kings and the Blackwoods the disloyal vassals than vice versa. Sort of puts the whole dispute in a different light, doesn’t it?

And if you look deeply, there’s always two sides to the same story – the Brackens backed the Ironborn because the Blackwoods had invited the Storm Kings to invade the Riverlands to make Lord Rodrick Blackwood King of the Rivers and Hills, which makes the Blackwoods rather horrendous traitors to their liege lords the Teagues. (Although they’d say they were fighting for their faith)  

Race for the Iron Throne Kickstarter

Race for the Iron Throne Kickstarter

image
So, after many delays, the big announcement that I’ve been talking about since the spring is finally here: the Race for the Iron Throne Kickstarter is live! The purpose of this Kickstarter is to raise money so that I can devote more of my time to writing about A Song of Ice and Fire, and specifically to enable me to jump-start several projects I’ve been talking about for a while: “Kings, Hands,…

View On WordPress