Given your opinions on the new Robin Hood and the…I guess hijacking of the O.G. Robin Hood, do you have any thoughts on the Ridley Scott/Russel Crowe Robin Hood? If I remember, he seems closer to the O.G. type you mentioned.

There haven’t been many good Robin Hoods recently. Prince of Thieves has the best Sheriff of Nottingham, but the rest was cheesetastic. 

The Disney one and the Errol Flynn one were at least fun, which should be an important part of the whole business. 

Hello, I have been getting confused since I hear a bunch of stuff on the internet but I thought Robin Hood was against the corrupt Catholic Church? Was he against the monarchy at first and then turned into a good king propaganda tool? Thanks.

If you go back to the original Geste of Robin Hood, you see the following:

“Then bespake him Little John
All unto Robin Hood:
‘Master, an ye would dine betimes
It would do you much good.’ Then bespake him good Robin:
‘To dine I have no lest,
Till that I have some bold baron,
Or some uncouth guest,…That may pay for the best,
Or else some knight, or some squièr
That dwelleth here by West.’

“…Thereof no force,’ then said Robin;
‘We shall do well enow;
But look ye do no husband harm
That tilleth with his plough.‘No more ye shall no good yeoman
That walketh by green-wood shaw;
Nor yet no knight nor no squièr
That will be a good fellaw.‘These bishops and these archbishops,
Ye shall them beat and bind;
The High Sheriff of Nottingham,
Him hold ye in your mind.”

This is a general anti-authoritarian position: he doesn’t like the clergy, he doesn’t like the royal officials, and he doesn’t like the aristocracy with the exception of those in the lower rakns who uphold the social contract.

However, he’s not anti-religious, he hangs around with Friar Tuck, he’s particularly devoted to the Virgin Mary (which is why he doesn’t kidnap or rob women), etc. 

It’s hardly the biggest issue with the new Robin Hood movie, but I have to ask. Was any European ever drafted into the Crusades?

A nobleman like Robin of Locksley? No. Noblemen served in the Crusades either as part of their feudal obligations to their liege lords or as volunteers. And the vast majority of commoners in Crusader armies were professional soldiers or volunteers too. 

On a separate topic, it pisses me off how working-class figure of resistance Robin Hood got turned into nobleman savior and good king loyalist Robin of Locksley. The Richard Lionheart loyalist stuff was added in the 16th century, and the nobleman thing didn’t come in until practically the 17th century. 

The O.G Robin Hood was an anti-monarchical yeoman. 

Hi. I recently read your economic development plans (really enjoyed them btw), and I was wondering how long it would take, roughly, for them to be fully implemented, assuming that each consecutive king/lord followed the same plan and there were no major wars or disasters halting progress? I’m especially curious about the North, Iron Islands, Stormlands and Dorne.

Decades and decades. This is long-term economic development. 

hedrigal:

Sheraton Hotel Workers in Stamford need your help. The Sheraton management have hired anti union law firm Cruz and Associates in order to bust the campaign to unionize the Sheraton.

Please call Thomas Carlos and tell him to fire these union Buster’s and allow the workers to organize in peace!

Why aren’t there term limits for US Senators? I wonder if the founders imagined that someone might serve as a senator for any longer than 12 or 18 years, wouldn’t they necessarily have to get another job at some point or die of old age?

There weren’t term limiits for any office in the Constitution originally, which suggests something of the Founders’ attitude to the idea. Not that we should necessarily go by what they thought. 

Fire and Blood, Volume I: Aegon’s Conquest to the Wars of Aegon I

Fire and Blood, Volume I: Aegon’s Conquest to the Wars of Aegon I

Here’s my plan with Fire and Blood, Volume I. This book is a bit of a tricky combination of stuff that’s taken word-for-word from previous texts (WOIAF, Sons of the Dragon, etc.), completely new stuff, and stuff that was in previous texts but has since been expanded.

In each post then, I will just link to where I wrote about the word-for-word stuff when the previous book came out, then continue…

View On WordPress

Since you’ve written about history podcasts recently, do you recommend Dan Carlin’s series on WWI? I just read Clark’s book on the origins of the conflict, and I’m much more interested in the political aspects of the war than on the purely military ones so I’m not sure this is the right source to listen to when it comes to what actually happened during the war itself. Do you have any other recommendations that I could look up on audio?

Carlin’s series is excellent on the military side, less so on the political or cultural side. 

In terms of recommendations, I would look to iTunesU for history courses from various universities. There’s probably a couple that have lectures on WWI from the angle you’re looking for.