What do you think was the Reyne/Tarbeck endgame? Say they defeat Tywin at Tarbeck Hall. Do they just go to Jaehaerys and say “Hey we just killed your son’s best friend, make us Lord Paramount”? Do they appeal for some sort of special autonomy?

I think the plan would have been to capture Tywin, force Tytos to either abdicate or name a Reyne as heir, and then turn around to Jaehaerys and say the Lannisters can’t keep the peace, only we’re strong enough to. 

Do you think any younger sons in Westeros ever go down to Dorne and try and make an impression on an heiress? Many of them get nothing out of life and have to make their own way in the world, Dorne is a place with a regular supply of ruling Ladies of their own house, surely some younger sons must go down there hoping to woo a Lady and have a nice life of luxury. Especially if they come from a house with decent enough power and good standing.

I’ sure it happens in Dorne, but unlikely to happen between regions. 

  • First, travel is slow and difficult at the best of times, and Dorne adds mountains and deserts to the question. Heiresses do pop up one’s own region, with less difficulty involved in wooing. 
  • Second, ruling ladies and heiress aren’t the same thing – in Dorne, marrying a ruling lady means wealth but no power. Consider the difference between Lady Hornwood vs. a Princess of Dorne; the consort doesn’t get the fief in the latter case. 
  • Third, there’s the historical and cultural baggage. Much of the South has been warring against Dorne for thousands of years, Dorne itself isn’t too keen on much of the South, etc. 

I was just reading some of your stuff on the Maekar-Bloodraven region. Is it canon that Bloodraven was Hand during Maekar’ s reign? I was thinking something could have happened after Maekar’ s death like happened during the Regent Wars, when Marston Waters “somehow” became Hand unexplainedly. Perhaps Bloodraven escapes and appoints himself? Yes, I prefer Maekar pre-region.

That was my reading of the WOIAF chapter, but this is a heavily retconned area that is more than a little confusing. 

elanabrooklyn:

(via Graphic Policy’s Top Comic Picks this Week!)

Every week the crew graphicpolicy makes a list of which comics we are most looking forward to buying today. This week we were joined by racefortheironthrone‘s own Steven Attewell!

Click above for the full list. 

Here are my own recommendations (for those who only want my opinions haha).

Top Pick: Grindhouse: Doors Open at Midnight: Trade Paperback Vol 3: Slay Ride and Blood Lagoon (Dark Horse) – “Books like ‘Grindhouse’ were the reason the Comics Code was invented.” – creator Alex De Campi.

That’s a promise and a warning. De Campi absolutely delivers on grindhouse cinema gratification in comic book form– even better, it comes from a frankly female perspective on the genre. This series is messed up in all the RIGHT ways.

Each trade contains self-contained story arcs so you can pick up volume 3 even if you’ve never read the series before. In Volume 3 my entirely fictional girlfriend, Deputy Garcia is back with her motorcycle and eyepatch. I can’t wait!

Series creator Alex de Campi is our podcast guest next week!

Batgirl Annual #3 (DC Comics) – Cameron Stewart and brendenfletcher art by Bengal, David Lafuente, Mingjue Helen Chen, mingdoyle…. Look at that list of awesome writers and artists! Not only do we get Babs catching up with Dick Grayson but we also see her meet with Batwoman and the Gotham Academy kids! These are all of my favorite things in one place! It is a standalone story you can read even if you aren’t reading the new Batgirl series. But after reading this I’m sure you’ll want to.

Diary of a Teenage Girl (North Atlantic Books) — Phoebe Gloeckner – Considered one of the best graphic novels of last decade it’s probably time that you (and I) finally read it! Plus there’s a movie of it coming out soon and you don’t want to be called a “poser”, right? The book is a combination of prose and illustration reads like autobiography. The press release calls it “a dark story of sex and drugs in the life of a 1970s teenage girl.” You should read Sean T Collins review because I can’t do it justice till I read the book.

1602 Witch Hunter Angela #2 (Marvel)Marguerite Bennett, Kieron Gillen, Stephanie Hans, Marguerite Sauvage 

This is the funniest series in Secret Wars and the prettiest too. Last issue we met Shakespeare, Marlowe and King James (Logan Howlett aka Wolverine) and other Faustians (aka people with superpowers). This issue Angela and Sera will meet “Ye Olde Guardians of the Galaxy.”

In terms of heirs marrying heirs, if Sansa married Willas Tyrell or he married Arianne Martell how would the inheritance of the mothers work? First son gets Highgarden while second gets mom’s, would a firstborn daughter get Dorne?

It’s a tricky situation, because we haven’t really seen the case of a house holding multiple holdfasts directly, and we’re told that there’s a tradition of not allowing that, and instead creating cadet branches.

My guess is that they’ll create cadet branches rather than trying to have the same family rule both locations. 

Addendum to the troop dispositions again, but even without the Riverrun and Raventree sieges the problems of bandits, rebels and outlaws also prevailed in the Riverlands to the point where Randyl Tarlly had his entire army at Saltpan/the southeast Riverlands at one point, I just find it hard to believe the Lannisters could afford in turn to leave such a small occupation force for the rest of the Riverlands until the area had stabilized a bit more.

I think the issue is that the Lannisters are mostly tapped out. They started the war with 45,000 men under arms – they lost 3,000 men at the Whispering Woods, 8,000 at the Camps, and 10,000 at Oxcross, and an unknown number at the Green Fork, the retreat from the Green Fork, raids and counter-raids in the Riverlands, the Battle of the Fords, and the Battle of Blackwater, which I think adds up to anywhere between 5,000 and 8,000 men. 

So at the point that Tywin dies, I think the Lannisters have about 12-15,000 men in Tywin’s army and another 2,000 or so that Daven has pulled from the garrisons of Casterly Rock and the Golden Tooth and the survivors of Oxcross. Of Tywin’s army, 2,000 gets sent to Dragonstone (1,000 of them die), 800 go with Jaime, 450 or so go with Tywin’s funeral escort, and the rest are demobilized when their lords leave for the Westerlands.

It’s not a question of affording any more – those 10,000 or so men have been under arms for the better part of two years, much longer than any normal term of feudal service. Tywin’s force of personality kept them them in the field, but once Tywin is dead, they’re not going to stay put, especially when the identity of the actual lord of Casterly Rock is so ambiguous. 

 

From again, I find that disposition of the Lannisters forces to be conflicting with Kevan’ s statement to Cersei in Danxce here he states that the best part of the Westerland forces were at Riverrun with Jamie, which doesn’t make sense in your breakdown of where there remaining forces are. Give Daven Lannisters presence as Warden of the West and commander of the siege before Jamie arrived is it not probable Westmoreland forces either rerouted to deal with Riverrun or remobilized?

Keep in mind that Kevan says that after the 2,000 men at Dragonstone have lost half their numbers, and Jaime’s forces have merged with Daven’s at Riverrun. 

There’s no evidence of remobilization or re-routing, and Daven’s inability to actually control the siege is strongly suggestive that he doesn’t have more troops than the 2,000 that the Freys have.