Do you think Westeros cities like Oldtown, King’s Landing, Lannisport, Gulltown, and White Harbor should have had more sicknesses? Like plagues such as the Spring Sickness. They are port cities who get a lot of travel and it seems a bit strange to me that we never really hear about a lot of quick spreading disease.

I mean, the Spring Sickness is kind of a major example, no?

The Winter Fever of 132-133 would be another. 

The Grey Plague of ~220 is another major example, with half of Oldtown and ¾ of the Citadel dying. 

The Headcanon Challenge: A Commentary on the True Life of the High Spider, Part II

The Headcanon Challenge: A Commentary on the True Life of the High Spider, Part II

image
A while back, JSLAL from Wars and Politics of ASOIAF got a really interesting question on Tumblr, asking him to come up with a character who could fill in some of the gaps in Westerosi history. I really liked his response, and so when I got the same question, I decided to see if I could do one better. (Much thanks goes out to @hiddenhistoryofwesteros and @cynicalclassicist for their assistance in…

View On WordPress

So I’ve been on a bit of an American Civil War kick recently and I’ve got a two parter for you: What do you think of George B. McClellan as a commander, and do you think he would have made a good president? Cheers!

1. Good at logistics and training, bad at everything else. As a commander, he defeated himself over and over again, either by assuming that the enemy had greater numbers than they did or through indecision as to when to commit resources. Even when given the enemy’s battle plan in advance, he only managed a draw. 

2. No, he would have been a terrible president. McClellan was utterly opposed to emancipation, freedmen serving in the U.S military, and civil rights for African-Americans. Most importantly, in 1864 his own party’s platform called for a cease-fire and negotiated peace, while McClellan ran on an impossible platform of continuing the war to restore the Union but not interfering with slavery, even as the war was destroying slavery. 

Hi. My question: how did people recognize each other as “nobility” worked, both in history and in ASoIaF? I mean, there weren’t IDs, and I doubt all the nobles in the country knew each other. I started wondering about it when Manderly referred to Davos as “lord Davos” in Dance of Dragons. I mean, he SAID he was a lord and the Hand of the King, but he neither sounded like lord, looked like a lord, and he came withour retinue etc. Wouldn’t Manderly think he was just shitting him?

Good question!

So heraldry is a big part of it, hence why we see highborn children drilled to recognize sigils and house words. The immediate practical benefit is knowing who’s who on the battlefield, but it works as well off the battlefield, so that you can avoid awkward social scenarios by making sure that nobles can tell the social status of other nobles, because a key part of noble identity/culture was being very touchy about their status being recognized. (Hence why a lot of conflicts in medieval literature come about when someone’s hiding their identity and thus isn’t treated with the deference due.)

Another part of it has to do with more subtle signs of class distinction, the things that a social climber would have to learn to fake. Accent and diction, dress and fashion, manners and mannerisms, the soft and hard skills taught to nobles, and so on. 

As for Davos, he’s a different case because he is somewhat famous – breaking the siege of Storm’s End, Stannis knighting a smuggler and taking his fingers, etc. Wyman Manderly would have heard about that and added Davos to the roll of known nobility. 

Hey, two questions: why aren’t you writing about the Crownlands in your Politics of the Seven Kingdoms? Also, how did you manage to write A Laboratory of Politics without TWOIAF and asearchoficeandfire? (to check the backstory and all that… I don’t think it existed in 2014?) Really love your work!

julianlapostat:

racefortheironthrone:

1. I find the Crownlands rather boring, sorry. Also, as far as the Politics of the Seven Kingdoms goes, there is no chapter on the Crownlands, so it only appears as a bit player in other stories. 

2. Hah! The answer is: extremely laboriously. I still had A Wiki of Ice and Fire and the app, which gave me hints of where to look, but mostly what I did was use the search function on my e-book copies of ASOIAF and look for every single mention of each of the Free Cities and compile lists of page numbers and then type out quotes manually. 

I wonder about that?

Because there’s potentially interesting material on the Crownlands, namely the city of King’s Landing itself. It’s the one city whose smallfolk we know a great deal about, and overall, it’s a double with the Riverlands which is a region which we mainly know through its smallfolk at least in ASOIAF. We have a strong grasp of the politics of the Kingslander smallfolk as well, their hatred and dislike for Tywin, the revolt of the Antler Men and so on. Let’s not forget that the two major Smallfolk POV in the entire series are Kingslanders (Ser Duncan and Ser Davos).

And of course the Crownlands includes Duskendale and that was the site of the only known charter uprising. And AFFC has a good deal of politics with the Merryweathers and Brienne’s visit to Duskendale…

Sure, I get that, but the bulk of Politics of the Seven Kingdoms is about covering the pre-Aegon political development of the Seven Kingdoms, so…