If you were writing a series of Cadfael-type Mysteries set early in the reign of Jaehaerys the First (think Dunk & Egg in Septon’s robes) then what area of the Seven Kingdoms & what aspects of the period do you think would make for the most interesting focus?

image

Great question!  

  • I would definitely recommend the Bracken/Blackwood feud and the disputed lands between their two castles as a good place for a murder mystery that can tie in to Jaehaerys’ mediation of the feud.
  • the North or the Wall during Jaehaerys and Alysanne’s progress and the handing-over of the New Gift.
  • Oldtown during the negotiations between the High Septon and Septon Barth over the disarmament of the Faith Militant.
  • the Inn at the Crossroads during a royal inspection of the Kingsroad.
  • the Great Tourney of 98 AC would be a great backdrop.
  • Aemon’s death and the Second Quarrel.
  • the Great Council of 101 AC and the Lannister gold. 

You’ve mentioned slave rebellions in the American south and post-civil war politics, but can you shed any light on the absence of slave rebellions or strikes during the war itself? At the least I can’t find much written on it.

Really? Because there’s been a ton written about it, ever since W.E.B DuBois’ Black Reconstruction (1935), which reinterpreted the mass exodus of slaves from the plantations to the Union Army as a general strike against the slave economy, was picked up again in the 1980s.

Some books I’d recommend that followed from DuBois’ work:

  • Vincent Harding, There Is a River (1981)
  • Eric Foner, Reconstruction (1988)
  • Ira Berlin et al., Slaves No More (1992)
  • Julie Saville, The Work of Reconstruction (1994)

RFTIT Tumblr Weekly Roundup

RFTIT Tumblr Weekly Roundup

Hey folks! Just to let you know that, while work on Politics of the Westerlands and Jaime II continues, updates might be a bit slower for the next few weeks because A. final papers have arrived and need to be graded and B. I’m going on vacation for a couple weeks, and while writing is inherently enjoyable to me, I will have social obligations to family and friends so my time will be a bit more…

View On WordPress

theladyinquisitors:

@urdnot replied to your photo: “amelie lacroix is tragic af and i support everything about her *slams…”:

i want her to have a recovery arc with zenyatta like think of the dynamic

have you read the widowtracer fic london calling? it actually does some really cool exploration of both their characters and i came away from it really loving the idea that amelie is dead, and when widowmaker eventually breaks her conditioning and joins overwatch, widowmaker herself will be dead, and whoever is left over will be an entirely new woman. it has some cool scenes with zenyatta to that effect (along with some speculation on what omnics having souls really means)

I’d also recommend the widowtracer fic Alive. Chapter 7 has Zenyatta and Genji in it, and it’s the best/spookiest portrayal of either of those characters I’ve ever seen:

“A door perhaps ten feet ahead of her along the side of the alley opened with a click. An Omnic stepped out, moving with the slow, graceful steps of their kind. Amélie’s eyes widened.

“What’s this?” Chen asked, amused, “You picked a bad time to take out the trash, tin-can!”

“On the contrary,” the Omnic said smoothly, “Although violence is not an answer I prefer to resort to.” He had a surprisingly fluid voice for an Omnic, a soft tenor that seemed to ooze calm self-control. 

Amélie’s eyes were still wide orbs as they traced the lines of the Omnic’s clothing. He was a slender man of steel, but his bare frame was draped in cloth of red and saffron yellow, and he wore a long necklace of metal beads in the style of a monk. He turned his head to examine her, and for a moment she was staring at the face of a dead man.

Only after a second’s searching of that face did she spot the difference; a forty-five degree shift of the glowing dots upon his forehead that aligned them in a square rather than a diamond. This was not Mondatta, who she had killed back in London’s King’s Row, thousands of miles from here.

“O-One of the Shambali?” she said incredulously, her voice a bare whisper. The Omnic nodded to her with such grace that it was almost a bow.

“Formerly,” he said easily, “Though I hope one day to return, and share what I have learned.”

“I’m sorry to interrupt,” the Talon leader said, raising a stubby black pistol, “But I have some pressing business with that woman.”

“Ah, my apologies,” the Omnic said, “But it appears I was here first. Perhaps you shall have to try another night.”

Amélie’s eyebrows rose at about the same time as Chen’s did.“You must be fucking joking! Damn but tin-cans are getting mouthy these days!” Chen laughed, raising the pistol to aim at him. That was apparently a cue, as all the rifles in the alley raised too. Amélie clenched her hands into helpless fists. Chen grinned.“Got any last words?” he asked, sarcastically. 

The Omnic monk nodded.“Yes,” he murmured, then raised his voice as if addressing a congregation. He swept his hand from left to right, as if gesturing to the crowd of mercenaries.“Human. Omnic. We are all one within the Iris.”

Chen rolled his eyes.“Kill them.”

A brilliant golden light blazed into being, forcing Amélie’s eyes to narrow, then shut for the space of a breath. When she opened them again, the light had dimmed to something merely dazzling. The Omnic monk stood there, his hands spread in a gesture of benediction. The light seemed to emanate from him, and from three extra sets of arms formed entirely of that golden light, spread in various gestures of warding and blessing that were entirely foreign to her.

The bullets that should have killed them were nowhere to be seen. The fire and thunder was a constant, deafening roar at the end of the alley, but no rounds seemed to reach them, seemingly unable to pass into the radius of the monk’s outstretched arms. The gunfire slowed, then staggered to an almost embarrassed halt. The last to cease fire was the Talon leader, who stepped closer and closer, emptying his pistol directly at the Omnic’s head-case, to no visible effect. His slide stayed back as the weapon clicked empty. He swore violently, tossing the gun at the monk, who brushed it aside with one hand, letting it clatter into the side of a trash can behind them.

That done, the light faded, the arms spread around him becoming more and more insubstantial before folding in upon themselves and disappearing. The men in the alley stared at him, as if witnessing a miracle. Several of them made what looked like religious or superstitious gestures of warding. The Talon officer looked back at his men, then at the pair of them, his face reddening.

“What the hell are you waiting for?! Shoot him! Shoot him!”

“I should warn you,” the monk said, raising one silvered hand, “That my pupil would not approve of such an action.”

“Your pupil?” Chen asked, dumbfounded.

There was a scream from around the corner; long, loud and terrified. The men turned, backing into the alley, rifles raised.“W-What does he do?” Chen stammered, his face draining until it was a pale, ghostly white.

“Oh,” the monk replied easily, “Whatever he thinks best.”

A Thanks to ASOIAF Analysts on Tumblr

the-winged-wolf-bran-stark:

Right, year-end post… well, not a year-end post. I mean, it is a year-end post, but it’s the only year-end post I’m making, and I’m going to dedicate it to one thing only.

So, 2016 has sucked. Like, for everyone. Even if you look at the various political events of the year as good things, I’m sure some famous person you liked died. A few hundred of them. Not a good year. Especially not for fans of A Song of Ice and Fire. Another year and still no release date for The Winds of Winter, let alone the book itself. I mean, we got The Forsaken, but still. 

Still, this was the year I started really reading analysis and theories of the series, and by analysis, I mean good analysis, not “Why Tywin Lannister is a better father than Ned Stark” analysis, and good theories, not “Cotter Pyke is a Secret Targaryen” theories. So…

Thanks to @poorquentyn for getting me properly interested in all these things. And turning me into a believer of the EA. The Eldritch Apocalypse, not Electronic Arts. One brings you despair, disbelief, and makes you wonder how the fuck any of this makes sense. The other involves demons, magical shenanigans, and general end of the world stuff. Also, reminder that Jaime is not on a redemption arc. Turned me into a believer of that as well. 

Thanks to @racefortheironthrone for his essays on the politics of each of the Seven Kingdoms and most especially, his chapter-by-chapter analyses. Very enlightening essays on various POV arcs both within the book and the series overall. I have newfound appreciation for Dany’s arc for one thing. Hopefully Winds will be out by the time you get to the FeastDance.

And thanks to @goodqueenaly, @nobodysuspectsthebutterfly, @warsofasoiaf, @joannalannister, @pretenderoftheeast, and… I think that’s it, actually. I probably forgot people, I’m sorry! Right, thanks for your own analysis of ASOIAF.

So thanks for both making the wait for TWOW more bearable and more excruciating. Which I’m quite sure is a contradiction, but hey, what can you do? Someday, perhaps, I’ll start doing my own analysis of the series, and eventually do a series on Bran Stark so I can become the Ultimate Bran Stark Trash. But first, I must obtain the most magical of ASOIAF powers, as it seems you all have obtained, more powerful than building a giant wall of ice, hatching dragons, birthing shadowbabies, and… whatever the fuck Euron is up to.

That power?

Memorize every single chapter in the series.

ONE DAY! *shakes fist*

Thanks very much! 

Well, I’m glad I could make a pretty lusy year somewhat better.

In terms of the secret power, the training method is simple: re-read the series multiple times. Then write about each chapter. Then make sure to always have A Wiki of Ice and Fire, Tower of the Hand, and ASearchofIceandFire open at all times so you can fake it. 

You mention your concept of a Westerosi Great Game in the Westerlands Politics of the Seven Kingdoms, and I wanted to know how you conceive of that era. Are there major “nexus points” other than the Riverlands for the Stormlands-Iron Islands and the Reach-Westerlands border? How important is the arrival of the Rhoynar and the unification of Dorne to this period? What do you want to know about it that there isn’t enough information on?

Well, keep in mind that the Riverlands aren’t just a nexus point for the Stormlands and the Iron Islands – we know that that the Kings of the Rock “warred against the many kings of the Trident,” we know that “the lords of the Reach sent iron columns of knights across the Blackwater whenever it pleased them,” and we know two kings from the Riverlands invaded the Reach during the reign of Gyles III.

Dorne was another important nexus – hence the political importance of the marcher lords in both the Reach and the Stormlands and the fierce independence of the mountain lords of Dorne – both before and after the arrival of the Rhoynar. Dorne’s role was to force both the Reach and the Stormlands to keep an eye on their southern borders and to pounce on any sign of over-stretch or weakness: Garth VII had to be nimble as hell to fight the Fowler Kings and the Ironborn at the same time, but when Gyles III looked to conquer the Stormlands, three Dornish kings invaded him; likewise, when Arlan III conquered the Riverlands, the moment he died the Dornish launched invasions over the Boneway.

So I would argue there are several levels that the Great Game operated on: there’s the Riverlands nexus (which includes the Westerlands, the Stormlands, and occasionally the Reach and the Vale, and would later include the Iron Islands), the Westerlands/Reach nexus, the Reach/Stormlands nexus, and the Reach/Dorne/Stormlands nexus. And all of these nexii were going on at the same time, making for a very complicated conflict.

In terms of the importance of the Rhoynar, we don’t know enough – we get a sense that Nymeria’s uniting of Dorne allowed them to successfully hold off invasions by the Stormlands and the Reach, and we get a few accounts of invasions of the Reach and the Stormlands by the Dornish, but most of that is during the pre-Martell phase. 

If Dany had put more effort into cultivating her propaganda image, commissions depictions of herself as a Harpy, tapping into Ghiscar’s shared history with the Valyrian empire, and captializing on the proto-personality cult among the freedmen, could she have forged Ghiscar into a formidable, unified power using quasi-nationalist sentiment?

No. Dany’s mistake was not in failing to genuflect in the direction of “Ghiscari” nationalism – remember all that business with the tokar? – but in failing to understand that there is not one Meereen, but two. There is the Meereen of the Masters and the Meereen of the slaves, and rather than choosing, Dany ended up falling between two stools.