What books / book series other than ASOIAF would you most like to see get the Game of Thrones treatment (i.e., a show on HBO with a massive budget)?

opinions-about-tiaras:

racefortheironthrone:

Oh, this is a fun one.

  • The Gentlemen Bastard series by Scott Lynch would be really fun. 
  • I’d love to see Sapkowksi’s Witcher novels given a high budget, especially after the CD Projekt Red adaptations. 
  • Tad Williams’ Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn series could be cool if they can cut down on Williams’ penchant for characters going slightly mad down in cave systems.
  • The Rivers of London urban fantasy by Ben Aaronovitch if they’re doing a joint BBC operation would be good.
  • Ken Liu’s The Grace of Kings would be an interesting departure from the often monochromatic quasi-Medieval European settings.
  • I’d love someone to do a Conan the Barbarian vignette series, if they can nail the tone of the Dark Horse adaptations.

I remain somewhat surprised the Peter Grant novels haven’t gotten adapted to the screen by the BBC yet. It capitalizes on urban fantasy, which remains hot these days, it’s unrelentingly British but also based on a property with moderate international appeal (important to the Beeb these days in many ways) and the nature of the magic in it is such that it can be handled on the cheap and still look good.

And that’s above and beyond them just being good stories.

Dunno either, especially as the project started as a spec script for a Torchwood-like magical police show, and the author has a background in British TV. 

What books / book series other than ASOIAF would you most like to see get the Game of Thrones treatment (i.e., a show on HBO with a massive budget)?

Oh, this is a fun one.

  • The Gentlemen Bastard series by Scott Lynch would be really fun. 
  • I’d love to see Sapkowksi’s Witcher novels given a high budget, especially after the CD Projekt Red adaptations. 
  • Tad Williams’ Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn series could be cool if they can cut down on Williams’ penchant for characters going slightly mad down in cave systems.
  • The Rivers of London urban fantasy by Ben Aaronovitch if they’re doing a joint BBC operation would be good.
  • Ken Liu’s The Grace of Kings would be an interesting departure from the often monochromatic quasi-Medieval European settings.
  • I’d love someone to do a Conan the Barbarian vignette series, if they can nail the tone of the Dark Horse adaptations.

A Parcel of Rogues in a Nation: On the Great Councils, Part II

goodqueenaly:

racefortheironthrone:

A Parcel of Rogues in a Nation: On the Great Councils, Part II

Seemingly for the first time in recorded history, lords from all over Westeros had gathered together. The greatest Targaryen king in history had summoned them together to provide a peaceful mechanism for deciding the succession of the Iron Throne. And thanks to the fecklessness of Viserys I, their work would make a peace that would last only 28 years.
(more…)

View On WordPress

An excellent conclusion to @racefortheironthrone’s discussions on the Great Councils of Westeros. It is quite nice indeed to point out that, despite her very clear flaws, Alicent was sane enough to recognize that a Great Council was a reasonable, even necessary, option in the escalating bloodshed of the Dance (although she was doubtless confident that Aegon II would emerge on top).

I’m very curious – although we’ll have to wait some years to find out, of course – what Bloodraven’s motivations behind calling the Great Council of 233 AC were. If Bloodraven wanted to be in firm control of the state again, then baby Maegor would have seemed the most obvious candidate for him to back, and a Great Council unnecessary; not only did the little prince have the clearest blood claim as the most senior male-line descendant of Maekar I, but as an infant Maegor would be subject to a regency for the better part of 16 years – a role which Bloodraven might have smoothly assumed to fill. It’s possible, if not indeed probable, that the palpable hatred toward Aerion warned Bloodraven that supporting his, Aerion’s, son as king would isolate him politically and perhaps lead to his ouster from power – but if that’s the case, what was Bloodraven’s plan? Whom did Bloodraven want to seat on the Iron Throne? There’s too little information to know at this point, though future Tales of Dunk and Egg and Fire and Blood Volume 2 will doubtless explain this further.

Excellent questions! 

TBH, I think Bloodraven did it because he knew that if he didn’t, the same dynamic that had happened when Aerys I was king would re-emerge, where discontent with the king’s inability to live up to the knightly standard or fulfill the social contract amplified Bloodraven’s own negative publicity through the old “evil councilor” meme, and gave additional strength to the Blackfyre cause.

After all, Blackfyre sympathies must have been strong enough to fear their influence on a Great Council, what with Haegon’s murder still unanswered.  

A Parcel of Rogues in a Nation: On the Great Councils, Part II

A Parcel of Rogues in a Nation: On the Great Councils, Part II

image

Seemingly for the first time in recorded history, lords from all over Westeros had gathered together. The greatest Targaryen king in history had summoned them together to provide a peaceful mechanism for deciding the succession of the Iron Throne. And thanks to the fecklessness of Viserys I, their work would make a peace that would last only 28 years.
(more…)

View On WordPress

How did ancient and medieval armies get their horses off their ships?

Great question!

One of the problems that had to be dealt with in medieval warfare was that you had all of these armies where the mounted knight dominated, but if you have to attack somewhere from the sea, you need to take your horses with you. 

And so a variety of strategies were used. For example, the Norman Invasion of 1066 involved a flotilla of longships which would land, and then horses would be led off the side of the ship and into the shallows/beach, as seen in the Bayeux tapestry:

image

And that works well as long as you control the beach-head and have time to get your horses off the ship, get them saddled and so forth, and then distribute them to their waiting riders. It’s not so good if your enemy are right there on the beach and able to disrupt your preparations. 

So by the time of the Fourth Crusade, we see specialized horse transports where knights could mount their horses on deck and charge straight off the side of the ship, presumably either via a ramp or gunwales that could be lowered: 

image

And they were quite successful, allowing the Crusaders to surprise the Byzantines with their speed and mobility and seize the vital fortress of Galata, which guarded the northern end of the boom chain that protected Constantinople’s Golden Horn. With the boom chain down, Venetian galleys could sail into the Golden Horn and launch amphibious attacks against the city’s less formidable northern walls. 

This question is actually for PoorQuentyn but I don’t have a login account. I wanted to ask if any of the fascinating “Eldritch stuff” going on in the Reach has any significance of what’s going on in the far north beyond the wall? If not, then what is the true point of Oldtown when there’s already a big threat with the Others? Thanks! :-)

Paging

@poorquentyn​…

I think yes, I think the Horn is going to be blown from the top of the HIgh Tower, because you’re supposed to be able to see the Wall from the top, which might indicate a magical line-of-sight thing.

Just finished the politics of the Stormlands (loving the series and can’t wait for Dorne) and I share your disappointment in the lack of detail in the early histories. Do you think there’s a Watsonian explanation? Maybe an attempt to appease the current royals with the most inoffensive history or the Baratheons trying to shift focus from the previous kings

Glad you liked it! I’m working on Dorne right now, actually.

I mean, they gave a Watsonian explanation, but it was that the history of the Stormlands is confusing, boring, and fragmentary. Which isn’t very compelling, tbh. 

If it was appeasing Robert, you’d think that it would be the longest history, full of heroic details of his ancestors’ victories…