It’s tricky, because there have been lots of different rosters that people have been attached to at various times – O5, Giant-Sized, the Australia team, Gold and Blue, etc.

IMHO, you start with the roster as it was in X-Men #129 – Cyclops, Phoenix, Storm, Nightcrawler, Wolverine, Colossus – with Kitty Pryde as an audience surrogate. That’s a solid and flexible core that you can easily add onto – Rogue, Gambit, Longshot, etc. – without losing the character dynamics.