Concerning your book v show about the bwb, I agree with you that the show creators botched their storyline. However knowing that they were never going to use LSH was their away to not only show the morally ambigous brotherhood properly but also their turn to the darkside that she represented? I can’t honestly see the bwb losing their way if Beric is around. Thoughts?

The problem is that you need the grace before the fall from grace otherwise it doesn’t land.

And the bigger problem is when you flip-flop on the BwB is bad – for example, going from Lem murdering Meribald to Beric showing up and hanging him. It’s thematically muddled. 

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.