What are your feelings about colonialism, or say about Niall Ferguson’s idea to justify it, do you feel the British Empire was a good or bad thing overall, or you think that a left-wing case can be made for it?

Colonialism is and was horrible, full stop, and any time or place someone tries to spin it as a positive, you can always find huge unmarked graves of human misery an inch below the dirt that’s been shovelled over them to hide them from view. Niall Ferguson is only the most recent of a bad bunch of apologists. He’s racist, homophobic, incoherent on economics, and of course, he’s a complete hack

The only left-wing case for empire I’ve ever heard of was Marx’s whole thing in the 1850s about Western imperalism forcing India and China to modernize (while still decrying the violence involved in that process), but that was based on some pretty Orientalist ideas about “Asiatic” backwardness and has been thoroughly abandoned. 

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.