Before the Others started their “final solution/apocalypse war” do you think they had Craster type relationships with other Wildlings(any of the nations, not just free folk)? And were they “do our bidding or we’ll kill you “-type deals or “give us your children and we’ll have fresh bear meat deliver itself to your village” -relationships. Also, do you think Val’s appearance is indicative of something significant?

I think it was more of the former. If you study Craster’s relationship, it’s not a relationship of equals or one he particularly understands – the Cold Gods come for reasons of their own, and they do not communicate their reasons to him. All he can do is obey and try to survive. 

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.